Each year, the Men’s College Squash Association awards All-American or Second Team All-American status to up to twenty top players in men’s collegiate squash. Additional players may also be awarded Honorable Mention All-American status. Additional information about selection criteria can be found in the Men’s Bylaws.
- 1969–1970 Men’s All-Americans
- 1971–1972 Men’s All-Americans
- 1972–1973 Men’s All-Americans
- 1973–1974 Men’s All-Americans
- 1974–1975 Men’s All-Americans
- 1976–1977 Men’s All-Americans
- 1977–1978 Men’s All-Americans
- 1978–1979 Men’s All-Americans
- 1982–1983 Men’s All-Americans
- 1983–1984 Men’s All-Americans
- 1984–1985 Men’s All-Americans
- 1985–1986 Men’s All-Americans
- 1986–1987 Men’s All-Americans
- 1987–1988 Men’s All-Americans
- 1988–1989 Men’s All-Americans
- 1989–1990 Men’s All-Americans
- 1990–1991 Men’s All-Americans
- 1991–1992 Men’s All-Americans
- 1992–1993 Men’s All-Americans
- 1993–1994 Men’s All-Americans
- 1994–1995 Men’s All-Americans
- 1995–1996 Men’s All-Americans
- 1996–1997 Men’s All-Americans
- 1997-1998 Men’s All-Americans
- 1998-1999 Men’s All-Americans
- 1999-2000 Men’s All-Americans
- 2000-2001 Men’s All-Americans
- 2001-2002 Men’s All-Americans
- 2002-2003 Men’s All-Americans
- 2003-2004 Men’s All-Americans
- 2004-2005 Men’s All-Americans
- 2005-2006 Men’s All-Americans
- 2006-2007 Men’s All-Americans
- 2007-2008 Men’s All-Americans
- 2008-2009 Men’s All-Americans
